Description

This game-used Louisville Bats New Era 59FIFTY cap was worn by Michael Toglia during his 2026 season in the Cincinnati Reds organization. The cap features a navy crown, bright red bill, and the classic Louisville “LB” logo embroidered in red and white. Inside, “Toglia” is handwritten beneath the crown, directly identifying it to the player, and the fitted size is 7 3/8.

Toglia was a first-round pick of the Colorado Rockies in the 2019 MLB Draft out of UCLA and spent parts of four seasons in the Majors with Colorado before joining Cincinnati on a minor league deal for 2026. He opened the year with Louisville and became one of the Bats’ biggest power threats, batting .273 with 22 home runs, 26 doubles, 65 RBI and a .920 OPS in 97 games. MLB.com

His strong Triple-A season earned him a promotion to the Cincinnati Reds on August 11, 2026. Before that call-up, Louisville had become the setting for a genuine comeback season for the switch-hitting first baseman, who brought several years of Major League experience and plenty of pop to the Bats lineup. MLB.com

Certified authentic as game-used by the Louisville Bats.

For Reds fans, Louisville Bats collectors, UCLA followers, or anyone who enjoys game-used memorabilia with a direct road-to-the-Majors story, this Michael Toglia cap checks all the boxes. It didn’t just sit in the team store — it belonged to the guy doing the hitting.

About Playing it Forward 502

About Playing It Forward 502: Playing It Forward 502 is a Louisville-area nonprofit that uses sports, community partnerships, and charitable events to create opportunities and give back to local families and organizations. Learn more at https://playitforward502.org.

Condition

Please note all items are "as-is where-is"

Terms and Conditions

1. All items are sold where is, as is.

2. Once payment is completed for item(s) won, the ability to schedule a pick-up time will become available. Scheduling a pick-up time is required. 

3. There will be a $20 fee assessed per item not picked up at that time that will be collected prior to bidding again at our auctions. Unlike retail, we do not have the option to store your item. If the item is larger than a standard suitcase (22" x 14" x 10"), we will charge $50 to the card on file per item to move the item.

4. Please plan accordingly as items not picked up are considered "abandoned". Do not bid if you can't pick up.

5. You are responsible for ensuring you collect all items at pickup.

6. Legacy uses "Popcorn" or "Extended" bidding. This means if a bid comes in at the last second, it is extended 3 minutes. This is like a live auctioneer saying, "going once" to ensure all bids are exhausted prior to closing.

7. We charge a 5% flat buyers premium on all charity items to cover credit card and operational costs.

8. We do not charge tax on 501c charity auctions.  All proceeds from the auction will go to Playing it forward 502. https://playitforward502.org

9. You must bring help to pickup any items. We can recommend movers upon request. Also, please bring tools for items that require disassembly.

10. Please read our complete terms and conditions for additional details.